Why Your 401(k) Match Isn’t Enough to Keep Your Top People
The retention gap is not about generosity. It’s about math.
Many companies believe their 401(k) match is a competitive benefit. They offer 4%, 5%, even 6% matching contributions. They add profit sharing. They communicate it well. And they assume it creates loyalty.
For rank-and-file employees, it does. But for highly compensated executives, the 401(k)—no matter how generous the match—is fundamentally capped. And the cap is the problem.
The Limits That Create the Gap
In 2026, the 401(k) elective deferral limit is $23,500 ($31,000 with catch-up contributions for those 50+). The total annual contribution limit (employee + employer) is $70,000. The compensation limit for calculating employer contributions is $345,000.
For an executive earning $500,000, the company’s 5% match applies only to the first $345,000 of compensation—a maximum employer contribution of $17,250. That’s the same match a $345,000 employee receives. The executive earning 45% more gets no additional benefit. The 401(k) treats them identically because the law requires it to.
Over a 20-year career, the compounding effect of this cap is dramatic. The executive accumulates $1.5–$2 million less than they would without the limit—a gap that translates to $80,000–$120,000 per year in retirement income they won’t have.
What Competitors Are Offering Instead
Companies that compete effectively for executive talent have moved beyond qualified plans. They offer SERPs that provide targeted retirement income above the 401(k) cap, nonqualified deferred compensation that allows unlimited deferral of current income, split-dollar arrangements that provide significant life insurance at minimal personal cost, and equity-equivalent plans for private companies that create long-term wealth accumulation tied to company performance.
Each of these tools exists outside the qualified plan system. They are selective (the company chooses who participates), flexible (benefits can be customized per executive), and retentive (vesting schedules create golden handcuffs).
The Cost Question
The most common objection is cost. But properly designed executive benefits—funded through COLI—can approach zero net long-term cost to the company. The premiums build tax-deferred cash value to fund the benefit, and the death benefit ultimately recovers the company’s investment. The company is not giving away money—it is deploying capital that comes back.
The real cost is not having these plans. It’s the cost of replacing a $400,000 executive: six months of vacancy, a search firm fee of 25–30% of first-year compensation, the productivity loss during transition, and the institutional knowledge that walks out the door. That cost dwarfs the premium on a COLI policy. SSG Financial Group can model the economics for your specific situation. Schedule a 20-minute consultation.
Ready to explore executive benefit strategies for your company?
Schedule a complimentary 20-minute consultation with SSG Financial Group.
Book Your 20-Minute Consultation
Learn more at www.ssgfingrp.com
About SSG Financial Group
SSG Financial Group provides integrated insurance and financial planning solutions for business owners, their executive teams, and their advisory partners. Our focus areas include executive benefits, wealth transfer, business transition planning, and ESOP repurchase liability funding.
